Typical asking rent in September 2026 ran from $1,734 a month in Lakewood to $2,989 on Bainbridge Island across 15 Kitsap, Pierce and Mason County towns. In all 15, that rent was lower than principal and interest on the town's typical home value at 7.11% with 20% down, by $341 a month in DuPont and by $3,313 on Bainbridge Island.

These are Zillow's Observed Rent Index figures for September 2026, the newest month in its city file when I read it on November 16, 2026. Home values are Zillow's Home Value Index for the same month, and the payment uses Freddie Mac's weekly survey rate for November 12, 2026. If you're moving here and deciding whether to rent first or buy on arrival, this is the monthly side of that question. It's information to plan with, not advice on which to choose.

Rent by Town, September 2026

The table lists every town in my service area with a page on this site and a September figure in Zillow's file. Rent is the typical asking rent. Home value is the typical home value, which is a model estimate of the middle of the market, not a sale price. The last two columns are my arithmetic, with the inputs shown further down.

Town County Rent, Sep 2026 Rent, Aug 2026 Typical home value, Sep 2026 Principal and interest Payment minus rent
Bainbridge Island Kitsap $2,989 $2,980 $1,170,933 $6,302 $3,313
Gig Harbor Pierce $2,632 $2,629 $811,439 $4,367 $1,735
DuPont Pierce $2,627 $2,614 $551,552 $2,968 $341
Bonney Lake Pierce $2,627 $2,673 $664,561 $3,576 $949
Poulsbo Kitsap $2,420 $2,426 $663,190 $3,569 $1,149
Puyallup Pierce $2,199 $2,198 $560,121 $3,014 $815
Silverdale Kitsap $2,093 $2,095 $601,583 $3,238 $1,145
Port Orchard Kitsap $2,006 $2,013 $555,588 $2,990 $984
Belfair Mason $1,922 Not published $478,269 $2,574 $652
University Place Pierce $1,916 $1,911 $647,629 $3,485 $1,569
Bremerton Kitsap $1,879 $1,869 $479,232 $2,579 $700
Steilacoom Pierce $1,805 $1,833 $633,343 $3,408 $1,603
Shelton Mason $1,803 $1,767 $418,789 $2,254 $451
Tacoma Pierce $1,773 $1,768 $482,647 $2,597 $824
Lakewood Pierce $1,734 $1,735 $510,189 $2,746 $1,012

Zillow's city file has no rent for Kingston, Seabeck, Manchester, Olalla or Union.

Hold three towns more loosely. The file has no August figure for Belfair, and its Belfair series only starts in April 2026. Shelton and Steilacoom start in December 2025. Tacoma and Bremerton run back to January 2015.

Typical asking rent beside principal and interest, by townIn all 15 towns the September 2026 typical asking rent is below principal and interest on the typical home value at 7.11% with 20% down.
  • Typical asking rent
  • Principal and interest
Bainbridge IslandTypical asking rent $2,989, Principal and interest $6,302
Gig HarborTypical asking rent $2,632, Principal and interest $4,367
DuPontTypical asking rent $2,627, Principal and interest $2,968
Bonney LakeTypical asking rent $2,627, Principal and interest $3,576
PoulsboTypical asking rent $2,420, Principal and interest $3,569
PuyallupTypical asking rent $2,199, Principal and interest $3,014
SilverdaleTypical asking rent $2,093, Principal and interest $3,238
Port OrchardTypical asking rent $2,006, Principal and interest $2,990
BelfairTypical asking rent $1,922, Principal and interest $2,574
University PlaceTypical asking rent $1,916, Principal and interest $3,485
BremertonTypical asking rent $1,879, Principal and interest $2,579
SteilacoomTypical asking rent $1,805, Principal and interest $3,408
SheltonTypical asking rent $1,803, Principal and interest $2,254
TacomaTypical asking rent $1,773, Principal and interest $2,597
LakewoodTypical asking rent $1,734, Principal and interest $2,746

Source: Zillow Observed Rent Index and Zillow Home Value Index, September 2026; Freddie Mac PMMS 30-year rate of 7.11%, November 12, 2026. Principal and interest is the author's arithmetic and excludes taxes, insurance and HOA dues.

See the numbers
Typical asking rent beside principal and interest, by town
ItemTypical asking rentPrincipal and interest
Bainbridge Island$2,989$6,302
Gig Harbor$2,632$4,367
DuPont$2,627$2,968
Bonney Lake$2,627$3,576
Poulsbo$2,420$3,569
Puyallup$2,199$3,014
Silverdale$2,093$3,238
Port Orchard$2,006$2,990
Belfair$1,922$2,574
University Place$1,916$3,485
Bremerton$1,879$2,579
Steilacoom$1,805$3,408
Shelton$1,803$2,254
Tacoma$1,773$2,597
Lakewood$1,734$2,746

August to September

Eight towns rose and six fell. The three moves larger than $13 are Shelton (up $36), Steilacoom (down $28) and Bonney Lake (down $46). Dollar differences in this post are taken between the rounded figures in the table.

September 2025 to September 2026

Twelve of the 15 towns have a figure for September 2025. The percent change is my arithmetic on Zillow's unrounded figures.

Town Rent, Sep 2025 Change to Sep 2026
Bainbridge Island $2,850 4.9%
Bonney Lake $2,512 4.6%
University Place $1,832 4.6%
Port Orchard $1,920 4.5%
Gig Harbor $2,537 3.7%
Poulsbo $2,338 3.5%
DuPont $2,559 2.7%
Bremerton $1,831 2.6%
Silverdale $2,040 2.6%
Tacoma $1,737 2.1%
Puyallup $2,163 1.6%
Lakewood $1,707 1.6%

Rent Beside the Monthly Cost of Buying

The inputs

The payment column is my arithmetic, not a quote.

  • Price: each town's typical home value for September 2026, the same Zillow figure this site's city pages use.
  • Down payment: 20%, so the loan is 80% of the value.
  • Rate: 7.11%, Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed average for the week of November 12, 2026.
  • Term: 30 years, 360 monthly payments, standard amortization. At 7.11% that is about $6.727 a month for every $1,000 borrowed.

Bremerton as the worked example: $479,232 at 80% is a loan of $383,386, and the payment comes to $2,579 a month. That is principal and interest only. It excludes property taxes, homeowners insurance and HOA dues.

Why the two columns are not like for like

The rent file I used is Zillow's smoothed series for houses, condos and apartments together (its file name reads sfrcondomfr_sm). It is one figure per town, not a rent for a three-bedroom house. The home value covers houses and condos. A detached house may well rent for more than its town's typical asking rent. And once taxes, insurance and HOA dues are added to the buying side, the monthly gap is wider than the table shows.

Rent First, or Buy on Arrival

What renting first does

On these figures, renting costs less per month in every town, and it leaves the down payment in your account. At 20% that is $83,758 in Shelton, $95,846 in Bremerton and $234,187 on Bainbridge Island. It also gives you a year on the ferry or the bridge before you commit to one side of the water.

Washington's rent cap makes part of that year more predictable. Under RCW 59.18.700, a landlord can't raise the rent during the first 12 months of a covered tenancy. After that the limit is 7% plus the Seattle-area consumer price index, or 10%, whichever is less. The Department of Commerce published 10% as the limit for January 1 through December 31, 2027. On Bremerton's $1,879, 10% is about $188 a month (my arithmetic).

Not every rental is covered. RCW 59.18.710 exempts, among others, a unit whose first certificate of occupancy was issued 12 or fewer years before the increase notice. My guide to renting first under Washington's rent cap covers the exemptions and the notice rules.

What buying on arrival does

On a fixed-rate loan the principal and interest stays the same for 30 years, while property taxes and insurance can change. Part of each payment is principal: in month one of the Bremerton example, $2,272 is interest and $307 is principal (my arithmetic). You also move once instead of twice.

The costs are the down payment, closing costs, selling costs if you leave in a few years, and the fact that home values can fall as well as rise. If you're arriving on orders, my guide to renting or buying on a PCS to Naval Base Kitsap works through tour length and which installation you report to.

Run your own numbers

The budget calculator takes your annual household income, a home price, a down payment and an interest rate. It returns an estimated monthly payment split into principal and interest, property tax and insurance, plus an estimated cash to close. Set the rate to 7.11%, or to what a lender quotes you, and put the total beside the rent column.

The cost of living page covers what neither column includes: sales tax, property tax, ferry fares, utilities and insurance. If you're down to two towns, compare them side by side.

Which Kitsap, Pierce and Mason County towns have the lowest rent?

By Zillow's typical asking rent for September 2026, the five lowest of these 15 towns are Lakewood ($1,734), Tacoma ($1,773), Shelton ($1,803), Steilacoom ($1,805) and Bremerton ($1,879). In Kitsap County the order from lowest is Bremerton, Port Orchard ($2,006), Silverdale ($2,093), Poulsbo ($2,420) and Bainbridge Island ($2,989).

Is rent lower than a mortgage payment in Kitsap and Pierce County?

In September 2026, yes, in all 15 towns in this post. Typical asking rent was $341 to $3,313 a month below principal and interest on the typical home value at 7.11% with 20% down. That leaves out property taxes, insurance and HOA dues, the principal a buyer pays down and the cash a renter keeps.

Does Washington's rent cap limit the asking rent on a new lease?

No. RCW 59.18.700 limits increases during a covered tenancy. It also says a landlord may set the rent at any amount after a tenant moves out and the tenancy ends, so the asking rents in this post are not capped.

Final Thoughts

In all 15 towns the September rent is smaller than the loan payment, and the difference depends on the town: $341 in DuPont and $451 in Shelton, more than $1,500 in University Place, Steilacoom, Gig Harbor and Bainbridge Island. Whether that makes renting first the better plan depends on how long you'll stay and how sure you are of the town.

If you want to work through your own timeline, talk to me or call (360) 777-7212. The free 77-page relocation guide covers the rest of the move.

This post is information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm rent rules with the Washington State Department of Commerce or the Attorney General's Office, and get rates and payments from a licensed lender.